Trend, Breakout, or Mean Reversion? Choosing Your Trading Strategy

Specific Investor Scenario

You’re looking at a chart of SBI. The price has been going up for three days. One person tells you, “Buy now, it’s a strong trend!” Another says, “Wait, it’s about to break out of its old high!” A third says, “Don’t buy yet, it’s too expensive; it will surely come back down soon.” Who is right? They are all describing different trading Ideologies.

Quick Answer

There is no “single” best strategy. Trend Following works in steady markets, Breakout works in volatile markets, and Mean Reversion works in sideways markets.

Official Fact: All systematic trading strategies, including those offered as “Wealth / Advice Packages” by brokers, must adhere to SEBI’s Investment Advisers Regulations. Always check if your strategy provider is a SEBI Registered Investment Adviser (RIA).

The Three Core Strategies

1. Trend Following (“The Trend is Your Friend”)

• The Idea: If a stock is going up, it is likely to keep going up.
• Method: You look for Moving Averages (like the 50-day or 200-day line). If the price is above these lines and sloping up, you buy.
• Risk: The “Trend” can end suddenly. This strategy often has a lower win rate but high “Risk-Reward” (small losses, big wins).

2. Breakout Trading (“Buying the Move”)

• The Idea: When a stock breaks above a price it couldn’t cross for a long time (Resistance), it signifies a sudden burst of new interest.
• Method: You set a Limit Buy Order just above the previous high.
• Risk: False Breakouts. The price crosses the line, you buy, and then it immediately crashes back down.

3. Mean Reversion (“What goes up must come down”)

• The Idea: Prices eventually return to their “Average” or “Mean.” If a stock is too far above its normal price, it’s “Overbought”; if too far below, it’s “Oversold.”
• Method: Using indicators like RSI (Relative Strength Index). If RSI is above 70, you sell. If below 30, you buy.
• Risk: A stock can stay “Oversold” or “Overbought” for a very long time, leading to deep losses if you bet against a strong trend.

Comparative Breakdown

Strategy	Market Condition	Indicator Used	Risk Level
Trend	Trending (Up/Down)	Moving Averages	Medium
Breakout	Volatile / Consolidating	Support/Resistance	High
Mean Reversion	Sideways / Flat	RSI / Bollinger Bands	Moderate

Practical Implication for Investors

• Don’t Mix Methods: If you enter a trade based on a Trend, don’t exit it just because an RSI indicator says it’s “Overbought.” Stick to the logic that got you into the trade.
• Stop-Loss is Non-Negotiable: Because Intraday and Swing trading involve betting on price movements, you must protect yourself against the 30-40% of the time when the strategy fails.
• Check the Volume: A breakout with low volume (low number of trades) is much more likely to be a “False Breakout.”

Action Items for Investors

1. Pick One and Master It: Don’t try to learn all three at once. Start with Trend Following as it is generally the most forgiving for beginners.
2. Backtest Your Idea: Look at 10 past charts. If you had used your chosen strategy, how many times would you have won? (This is called “Backtesting”).
3. Verify Broker Tools: Many brokers provide “Scanner” tools that automatically find Trend or Breakout stocks. Ensure you understand the settings before using them.

Verification Link

NSE Academy resources on Technical Analysis Concepts: nseindia.com/education/knowledge-center

---

Verify current status at nseindia.com, bseindia.com, or msei.in before trading.